Natalie Garza (born October 13 1982) is an American actress of film and television. She has appeared on such TV series as Gilmore Girls The 12th Man Half and Half Presidio Med How I Met Your Mother and has a recurring role as Faith on the Oxygen series Campus Ladies. Her film debut was in 2007's The List. In 2005 Natalie and her identical twin sister Nicole Garza became the Doublemint Twins.